Accidents involving brake checking are more common than many drivers realize and can lead to significant injuries, especially for the driver in the trailing vehicle. In Florida, one question often arises after a crash like this: Is brake checking legal in Florida? The short answer is no—it is not. Brake checking is considered a dangerous and reckless driving behavior, and it can have severe legal and financial consequences.
Rear-end collisions are responsible for a substantial percentage of all car accidents. In fact, according to the National Safety Council, rear-end crashes account for 40.8% of all accidents. These accidents often happen due to aggressive driving behaviors like brake checking or tailgating, both of which can quickly escalate into dangerous situations.
If you have suffered injuries in a crash where the other driver intentionally brake-checked you, or if you were following another vehicle too closely when the accident occurred, you may have legal grounds to pursue compensation.
Even though rear-end collisions often lead to the assumption that the trailing driver is at fault, proving that brake checking caused the crash can shift responsibility onto the driver who engaged in this reckless behavior.
Our experienced Fort Lauderdale car accident lawyers understand the complexities of Florida’s traffic laws and are here to help you determine your next steps. In the following sections, we’ll explore the legality of brake checking in Florida, what it involves, and how these types of accidents can affect your legal rights.
If you were involved in a brake-checking accident, keep reading to learn how you can protect your rights and pursue the compensation you deserve.
Brake checking is the reckless act of intentionally slamming on your brakes to force the vehicle behind you to react quickly—either by braking suddenly or swerving to avoid a collision. This often happens when a driver feels tailgated or wants to assert control on the road.
While the driver initiating the brake check may think they’re in the clear, it’s a dangerous behavior that can result in serious accidents, especially rear-end collisions.
Brake checking is a reckless behavior that poses serious risks to everyone on the road. While none of the reasons for brake checking justify the danger it causes, understanding why it happens helps highlight its hazards. Common causes include:
Brake checking is illegal in Florida and is categorized as reckless driving. Florida Statutes Section 316.192 defines reckless driving as operating a vehicle with a willful disregard for the safety of others. When a driver suddenly slams on their brakes to force a rear driver to react quickly, it creates a dangerous situation, often leading to rear-end collisions.
This behavior can result in severe penalties, including fines, license points, and potential jail time, especially if the action causes injury or death.
In addition to reckless driving laws, Florida also prohibits tailgating, which often leads to brake checking incidents. According to Florida Statutes Section 316.0895, drivers are not allowed to follow too closely behind another vehicle.
The law requires drivers to maintain a safe following distance based on traffic conditions, road conditions, and the speed of the vehicles involved. Brake checking is never an appropriate response to tailgating. Instead, the safest course of action is to move out of the way and report reckless driving to the authorities.
To prevent accidents, Florida law requires drivers to maintain a “reasonable and prudent” following distance behind the vehicle ahead. A widely recommended guideline is the three-second rule: choose a fixed point on the road (like a sign or tree), and when the car in front of you passes it, start counting. If it takes less than three seconds for you to reach the same point, you’re following too closely.
In difficult driving conditions—such as rain, fog, or heavy traffic—it’s best to extend this following distance to five or even ten seconds. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) reports that rear-end collisions, often caused by tailgating and brake checking, are responsible for approximately 30% of all serious traffic injuries.
Maintaining a safe distance can help you react to sudden stops or other hazards without causing a crash.
While following too closely is against the law, Florida also regulates driving too slowly, which can contribute to dangerous driving behaviors. Florida Vehicle Code Sec. 316.183(5) prohibits drivers from operating their vehicles at speeds that block or impede the normal flow of traffic, except in certain circumstances such as road conditions or safety concerns.
If you’re driving too slowly, it can frustrate drivers behind you, leading to tailgating or even brake checking.
In addition, Florida Statutes Section 316.183(2) establishes minimum speed limits on highways with four or more lanes. For example, on highways with a 70 mph speed limit, the minimum speed is 50 mph.
Driving below this minimum can create traffic hazards, especially for drivers trying to maintain a safe distance. Impeding the flow of traffic increases the likelihood of aggressive driving, including tailgating and brake checking.
It’s important for all drivers to obey speed limits and ensure they are not causing unsafe driving conditions by driving too slowly. By maintaining a reasonable speed and following at a safe distance, you can help prevent brake checking accidents and keep the roads safer for everyone.
In typical rear-end collisions, the trailing driver is generally considered at fault, as they are expected to maintain a safe following distance. However, brake checking complicates this rule. If a driver deliberately slams on their brakes to force the vehicle behind them to react, the driver initiating the brake check may be held responsible for the accident and any resulting injuries or damages.
Fault is assessed based on the specific actions of each driver. For example, the first vehicle that brake-checked may be primarily at fault, but other drivers may share responsibility if they were tailgating, driving too fast for conditions, or failed to maintain a safe distance.
Florida follows a modified comparative negligence system (per Florida Statutes Section 768.81), meaning that each party’s degree of fault is evaluated, and compensation is adjusted accordingly. If a driver is found to be more than 50% at fault, they are ineligible for compensation.
A chain-reaction accident, often referred to as a multi-vehicle collision or pileup, occurs when a single incident causes a series of rear-end crashes involving multiple vehicles. These types of accidents are common in Florida, particularly in high-traffic areas, and they present unique challenges in determining fault and liability.
When a brake-checking incident leads to a chain reaction, the driver who initiated the brake check is typically considered responsible for the accident, as their actions created the initial danger. However, determining liability can be more complicated in multi-vehicle accidents, as all drivers involved may have contributed in some way to the collision.
In multi-car accidents, determining which insurance pays for damages can be complex. Florida’s Personal Injury Protection (PIP) insurance covers medical expenses and lost wages up to the policy limit, regardless of fault. However, if the damages exceed the limits of PIP or if there are disputes about liability, the at-fault driver’s insurance will be responsible for covering the remaining damages.
If multiple drivers are involved and share partial blame, insurance companies may contest liability, which can delay claims and complicate the payout process. This is why having an experienced Florida personal injury lawyer on your side is crucial.
Your lawyer can help gather evidence such as witness statements, police reports, and expert testimony to establish the cause of the accident and ensure that the responsible parties are held accountable.
In situations where damages surpass the at-fault driver’s insurance coverage, additional options such as seeking compensation from other liable parties, using uninsured motorist coverage, or pursuing legal action against negligent third parties (e.g., road maintenance failures) may be explored.
Proving that brake checking caused your accident can be challenging, especially when the typical assumption is that the trailing driver is at fault in a rear-end collision. This perception can sometimes lead police officers, insurers, or even judges to automatically place blame on the rear driver, even if brake checking was the cause.
However, with the right evidence, you can prove that the other driver’s reckless behavior was the primary cause of the crash. Here’s the kind of evidence that can help build your case:
Eyewitness testimony can be crucial in brake-checking accidents. If anyone saw the driver in front suddenly slam on their brakes, their statement can help verify your version of events. Witnesses who can confirm that the other driver engaged in brake checking can make a significant difference in proving negligence.
If you or another vehicle involved in the accident had a dashcam, the footage can provide clear evidence of the brake check. Dashcam footage often captures events leading up to the crash, including sudden braking, which can be crucial in proving that the driver ahead intentionally caused the accident.
The police report from the scene of the accident can provide important information, including the official details of the crash, any statements made by the involved drivers, and evidence gathered by law enforcement. This document can help corroborate your version of events and show that the other driver was responsible for the unsafe situation.
In some cases, you may need the help of an accident reconstruction expert who can analyze the crash dynamics. These experts can assess vehicle damage, crash patterns, and other factors to demonstrate that the other driver’s sudden braking caused the accident. They can provide a professional opinion that supports your claim and help clarify how the brake check led to the crash.
The type and location of the damage to your vehicle can also be telling. In brake-checking accidents, the rear-end damage may show distinct signs of sudden, forceful braking by the vehicle ahead. A trained professional can analyze this damage to determine whether it aligns with a brake-checking scenario.
By gathering these types of evidence, you can build a strong case to prove that brake checking was the primary cause of your accident.
At Schilling & Silvers Personal Injury & Car Accident Lawyers, we have extensive experience helping clients navigate the complexities of car accident claims, including those involving brake checking and multi-vehicle collisions.
Our team of skilled Fort Lauderdale car accident attorneys understands the nuances of Florida’s traffic laws and is dedicated to advocating for the rights of those who have been injured in accidents caused by negligent or reckless drivers.
If you’ve been involved in a brake-checking incident or any other type of car accident, we are here to guide you through the legal process, ensure your rights are protected, and fight for the compensation you deserve. Contact us today for a free consultation and let us help you take the next steps toward recovery.
Our Personal Injury Law Offices
Fort Lauderdale Office
1700 NW 64th St Suite 460
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33309
(954) 712-8877
Hialeah, FL Office
2300 W 84th St Ste 213
Hialeah, FL 33016
(954) 712-8877
